Reviews Midsize Sedan Comparison Test: Camry, Sonata, Accord and Mazda6

17:34  24 january  2018
17:34  24 january  2018 Source:   MSN

Honda 2018 Accord Ticks Every Box

  Honda 2018 Accord Ticks Every Box <p>A new sportier exterior with an upgraded interior take it up a notch but the addition of two new turbocharged engines and a new available 10-speed automatic transmission rockets it ahead of the outgoing model.</p>Not only is the scenery breathtaking, the roads – now devoid of RV’s and tourists – are perfect for taking a car through its paces.

Wake up! Reports of the demise of the common passenger car are premature. Though we’ve been bombarded with statistics about the resurrection of the sport/utility vehicle, the ,000- to sub-,000 front-wheel-drive midsize sedan business remains strong and cutthroat

Lester Tista: The Mazda 6 and the Hyundai Sonata . Umer Zafar: Toyota camry The best. For our most recent midsize sedan comparison test we rounded up a group of six strategically selected entries and headed out on a 400-mile loop.

It’s an immensely popular segment in North America—especially in the U.S.—but sales have been slowing down significantly in the past couple of years. Midsize sedans are being traded in for sport-utility vehicles which are considered more practical. But not necessarily so.

Refreshing or Revolting: Mazda RX Vision vs. Mazda Vision Coupe

  Refreshing or Revolting: Mazda RX Vision vs. Mazda Vision Coupe <p>Which futuristic Mazda concept wore it better?</p>On the outside, both cars have a remarkable amount in common. Yes, the RX Vision is two years old and has two fewer doors than the Vision Coupe, but if you saw both on the street, there would be no doubt they're related. They have very similar sloping rooflines, and the sheet metal almost has a liquid appearance.In fact, most of what looks like design lines are actually light reflecting off the curved surfaces and flared fenders.

2013-14 Mid - Size Sedan Comparison Test : Toyota Camry vs Honda Accord vs Mazda 6 and more - Продолжительность: 10:05 AutoGuide.com 731 759 просмотров. [CRASH TEST ] 2016 Mazda 6 vs 2016 Hyundai Sonata - Продолжительность: 2:22 Better Car 144 696 просмотров.

2014 Midsize Sedan Comparison - Kelley Blue Book. It's a full segment comparison between the best family sedans including the Toyota Camry , Honda Accord , Nissan Altima, Mazda 6 , Hyundai Sonata , Subaru

Research

Research

After all, a midsize sedan offers plenty of room for four people, or five with a little shoulder contact. It has a huge trunk with fold-down rear seats to slide in longer objects. And it has fuel-efficient engines that—in some cases—consume barely more than the powertrains of compact-sized cars. A midsize sedan has so much to offer and demands little in return, and yet, consumers are deserting them for clumsy, fuel-sapping trucks.

There isn’t much manufacturers can do to stop the sales slide. And to be honest, they’re probably making better profit margins selling their SUVs anyway, so losing a few sedan sales might not be much of a concern.

Still, consumers who prefer driving cars have a wide selection of midsize sedans to choose from—and they’re all good vehicles. As two of the segment benchmarks received a redesign for 2018, it was time to set up a little comparison test.

2018 Toyota Camry First Test Review: Big Improvement but is it Enough?

  2018 Toyota Camry First Test Review: Big Improvement but is it Enough? The Toyota Camry is still the one to beat in the midsize car segment. Sales through October of this year already total 308,759. The only other sedan close to that level is the Honda Accord at 277,542 for the first 10 months. So with everyone in the field gunning for the all-new 2018 Camry, we were anxious to get some of our own test numbers to see if the king has pedigree worthy of retaining the crown for the foreseeable future.

In-Depth Reviews First Drives Instrumented Tests Comparison Tests Long-Term Tests Archived Reviews View All Reviews. Comparisons · December 2005. 2006 Ford Fusion, vs. Honda Accord , Hyundai Sonata , Toyota Camry .

It's a full segment comparison between the best family sedans including the Toyota Camry , Honda Accord , Nissan Altima, Mazda 6 , Hyundai Sonata , Subaru Legacy, VW Passat Proper Gods: I dare you to test this based on reliability. Hint( Camry will be #1. Talan Ochoa: Mazda????? Hahahahha.

We rounded up the Honda Accord and the Toyota Camry, but also the Hyundai Sonata, which received significant updates for the 2018 model year. We also threw in our long-time midsize sedan favourite, the Mazda6, as a measuring stick. The category also includes the Chevrolet Malibu, the Nissan Altima, the Volkswagen Passat, the Ford Fusion, the Subaru Legacy and the Kia Optima, but none of these received major changes this year.

We hit the road with our quartet of sedans, and after some extensive driving and infotainment system finger poking, a winner was declared.

4th place: 2017 Mazda6

This might be one of life’s greatest automotive mysteries. Then again, there probably is a logical explanation for the Mazda6’s struggle on the sales charts, in both Canada and the United States.

Redesigned for the 2014 model year, the 6 instantly became the most beautiful midsize sedan on the market—in our opinion, at least. It was also the best-handling car in its segment, staying true to Mazda’s fun-to-drive DNA.

Honda Accord, The Car Guide’s Best New Car of the Year for 2018

  Honda Accord, The Car Guide’s Best New Car of the Year for 2018 The Honda Accord midsize sedan, completely redesigned for 2018, was named the Best New Car of the Year by The Car Guide ’s team of journalists. The list of category winners for The Car Guide’s Best Buys for 2018 can also be found on our website. With a bold new …With a bold new design, new powertrains and new technologies, the Accord sedan has everything to please a clientele composed of both young and not-so-young buyers.

Midsize sedan comparison tests used to be fairly straightforward; there was the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry , usually finishing in that order, and all the rest. And while the Accord still holds up quite well, it is now in the thick of a competitive.

The Accord and the Mazda 6 were rated at 29.8 and 29.4 respectively. In an “observed MPG” test list this one that is a statistical tie. In all the other mid - size sedan comparisons , the Optima rates higher than both the Sonata and Camry (as well as the Altima).

Well, midsize sedan buyers are obviously not looking for a sporty car. The Mazda6’s 2.5-litre engine is competitive at 184 horsepower, but lacks the low-end torque of the new, smaller-displacement, turbocharged powertrains served up by more and more manufacturers. And it’s no longer one of the most efficient, although it did end up being the observed fuel economy champ of our test.

Our car was also equipped with a manual transmission—an automatic 6 wasn’t available for us—which enhanced our appreciation of the car’s dynamic character. The optional six-speed automatic transmission does perform admirably though, as we’ve tested it on numerous occasions.

The Mazda6’s interior design is clean and tasteful, even after being on the market for four years, while fit and finish are excellent. Some of us love the Mazda Connect infotainment system’s interface, some despise it. It does take a while to get used to the menu layout, but once we do, it becomes very easy to use without being distracted while driving. The navigation map graphics could be better, though, while Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration isn’t available. Moreover, the sedan’s cabin seemed noisier than the three other contestants here.

2018 Hyundai Sonata 2.0T First Test Review: Quicker and More Agile

  2018 Hyundai Sonata 2.0T First Test Review: Quicker and More Agile A fresh look at Hyundai's middling midsizerDespite many changes, Hyundai kept the same engines. Most buyers will find the standard 2.4-liter engine sufficient with 185 hp, as we've noted before. The 2.0-liter turbo-four engine still makes 245 hp and 260 lb-ft of torque, but it receives a new eight-speed automatic transmission. The turbocharged Sonata drives like a V-6 without feeling bulky.

In-Depth Reviews First Drives Instrumented Tests Comparison Tests Long-Term Tests Archived Reviews View All Reviews. Fourth: 2016 Toyota Camry SE. Third: 2016 Honda Accord Sport. 2017 Hyundai Sonata . Sounding off on Hyundai's mid - size sedan : a jazzy tune or the blues?

2013-14 Mid - Size Sedan Comparison Test : Toyota Camry vs Honda Accord vs Mazda 6 and more. It's a full segment comparison between the best family sedans including the Toyota Camry , Honda Accord , Nissan Altima, Mazda 6 , Hyundai Sonata , Subaru

As for trunk space, the Mazda has the smallest one of the bunch. It’s also the one with the tallest liftover height and the smallest opening.

The 6 doesn’t feel all that old, but compared to these newer rivals, it inevitably ends up showing its shortcomings. Not too long after we tested the 2017 edition, a reworked Mazda6 was announced for 2018. It will get an exterior refresh, an optional turbocharged engine and more active driving aids, but we’re not sure it would’ve moved up from last place in this comparison test. The others are that good.

3rd place: 2018 Hyundai Sonata

Here’s a sedan that does everything well, but fails to amaze in one particular aspect. That’s the big difference between the Sonata and the newly engineered models in our test, the Camry and the Accord.

We like the 2018 Sonata’s exterior styling, destined to make the car look a bit edgier than before. However, we’re not convinced the changes actually improve the overall design. Then again, it’s not a big deal in the midsize sedan segment, where conservatism seems to be the key strategy to attract buyers. The Sonata draw the highest marks for its exterior fit and finish.

Inside, Hyundai sweated the details in regards to ergonomics, and as usual, buyers get a lot of features for the asking price. The infotainment system is straightforward, with a reactive touchscreen and a fair amount of physical buttons for quick access to main audio and climate control functions. Outward visibility is pretty good, passenger volume is tops in this group, and the advanced driving systems are effective without being annoying. Unfortunately, as is the case with the Mazda6, the Sonata’s cabin could be quieter—at least compared to the segment newcomers.

2018 Honda Accord wins North American Car of the Year award

  2018 Honda Accord wins North American Car of the Year award Honda Odyssey and Lincoln Navigator take the Utility and Truck of the Year categoriesVideo: Honda Insight reintroduced at 2018 Detroit Auto Show (provided by Autoblog) Your browser does not support this video require(["binding"], function (binding) { binding("wcVideoPlayer", "#video_player_ec30c10c-71fa-4f52-a956-8916b89fcd99").

2014 Midsize Sedan Comparison - Kelley Blue Book. It's a full segment comparison between the best family sedans including the Toyota Camry , Honda Accord , Nissan Altima, Mazda 6 , Hyundai Sonata , Subaru

Four-Door Faceoff: PM's Midsize Sedan Comparison Test . Midsize sedans dominate American driveways. And three big players—the Nissan Altima, the Toyota Camry and the Honda Accord —have long dominated the market.

Our test car was equipped with a 245-horsepower, 2.0-litre turbo engine, but most customers will choose the base 185-hp, 2.4-litre four. We’ve driven the latter and it’s perfectly suited to the car’s mission; the turbo engine is just icing on the cake, but it does give the sedan some much-needed character. The Sonata’s handling didn’t impress us much, despite us having the sportiest trim level of the car’s lineup. Actually, besides a slightly different steering system and larger wheels, this version’s distinctiveness is more cosmetic than dynamic.

In the end, the Sonata’s virtues couldn’t overcome its slight lack of refinement and overall blandness, as three out of our four testers ranked it fourth in regards to overall personal preference. Still, its total score is close to its rival sitting in second place, and that’s nothing to be ashamed of.

2nd place: 2018 Toyota Camry

With the Camry XSE, Toyota is obviously trying to draw the attention of a younger crowd. Its hey-look-at-me styling, further enhanced by its cloak of bright blue paint, black roof and quad exhaust tips, is as overdone as the Mazda6’s design is pure and elegant. And yet, underneath the plethora of lumps, bumps and cosmetic add-ons, the Camry’s usual goodness remains intact. And the exterior design of most trim levels is more conservative anyways.

The highest scores for interior design as well as build quality were handed to the Camry. The Toyota was also voted the quietest car of our quartet. However, a heated steering wheel isn’t offered in the Camry at any price. The Entune 3.0 infotainment system doesn’t have the most user-friendly interface in the business, and it doesn’t integrate Apple CarPlay or Android Auto yet. However, it’s quick and its on-screen button zones are big.

Comparison Test: 2018 Honda Accord vs Toyota Camry vs Hyundai Sonata

  Comparison Test: 2018 Honda Accord vs Toyota Camry vs Hyundai Sonata <p>While it may not be quite as popular a segment as it once was in Canada, 2018 is nevertheless looking like the year of the midsize sedan if our three competitors in this test are any indication.</p>Dan Heyman, Simon Hill, and Brendan McAleer

The other midsize sedans we tested achieved similar combined mpg figures with two fewer cylinders. The Sonata was named one of Kelley Blue Book's Best Family Cars for 2015 along with the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry .

2018 Chevrolet Cruze TD Hatchback First Test . Car Comparison Tests . BMW 740e vs. Lexus LS 500 vs. Genesis G90 3.3T vs. L Midsize sedans continue to rock the U.S. sales board, with the Toyota Camry , Nissan Altima, and Honda Accord taking the fourth through sixth spots in the first quarter of

Passenger volume in the new Camry is down compared to the outgoing generation, while the new Accord has become slightly more spacious inside. The Toyota’s trunk is marginally roomier than the last-place Mazda’s, but at least its opening is bigger.

As is the case with the Sonata we tested, the Camry we had on hand was equipped with the bigger engine, though most buyers will be happy with the base 203-hp, 2.5-litre four cylinder which, by the way, is the most frugal non-hybrid powertrain in its segment. Almost every other manufacturer has shifted to turbocharged, smaller-displacement engines, but the Camry is sticking with an optional V6 for now.

The 3.5-litre unit pumps out 301 horsepower, which overwhelms the front wheels in certain driving situations. On the other hand, it gives the car a smooth and refined character, and sounds better than any turbo four-cylinder engine will in a midsize sedan. The compromise is higher fuel consumption, and our test car was pre-emptively equipped with winter tires, which gave it an unfair disadvantage here.

The sportiest Camry truly is, yet remains a Camry at its core. Straight-line acceleration is obviously very good, but the V6 engine makes the car feel heavier than its rivals here, and its brake feel was the worst of the group.

Still, the Camry ranked second for its combination of refinement, ride quality, cabin quietness and interior design. Things we think the midsize sedan is typically looking for a car.

1st place: 2018 Honda Accord

The Accord has been entirely redesigned, rides on a new platform and even adopts a new generation of powertrains. In short, only the name and its mission haven’t changed.

The more we look at new Accord, the more we appreciate its new exterior design. It follows the current trend of fastback-like silhouettes and looks both elegant and sporty at the same time. We won’t go as far as saying it’s a masterpiece, but for a Honda, it’s a big change.

The State of Accord and Camry: All New at the Same Time for the First Time Ever

  The State of Accord and Camry: All New at the Same Time for the First Time Ever The State of Accord and Camry: All New at the Same Time for the First Time EverThe Accord and Camry assimilated into American culture so thoroughly that they have long ceased being foreign at all. They’re largely engineered here, built here, and have topped the sales charts here for so long that millennials, post-millennials, and post-post-millennials don’t consider them anything but America’s most ubiquitous cars. Forget all the other minnows in the sedan mainstream. The Accord and the Camry are the big fish; the rest are swimming hard in their wake. And now, for the first time in the Accord’s 42 years and the Camry’s 35, they’re both all new at the same moment.

As two of the segment benchmarks received a redesign for 2018, it was time to set up a little comparison test . We rounded up the Honda Accord and the Toyota Camry , but also the Hyundai Sonata We also threw in our long-time midsize sedan favourite, the Mazda 6 , as a measuring stick.

A tasteful design can also be found inside the new Accord. The woodgrain trim in our test car is convincing, both front and rear seats were deemed the most comfortable, there is plenty of storage space for everyone, it’s got the biggest trunk and there’s little to criticise here about the control layout. The Display Audio System with eight-inch touchscreen is easy to use—a big improvement over the previous-generation Accord’s interface—and integrates Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, too.

We did notice some fit and finish issues inside and out of our test car, and the exterior panel gaps were wider than the current industry norm. Nothing major, mind you, but something we’re not used to seeing in and on an Accord.

We were impressed with the turbocharged, 1.5-litre four-cylinder engine that serves as the base powerplant. Its 192 horsepower, but especially its generous low-end torque, provide swift performance. And yet, it’s one of the most fuel-efficient non-hybrid engines in the midsize sedan segment. Complementing this engine is a continuously variable automatic transmission that we actually like. A 252-hp, turbo 2.0-litre engine is also available for those who want extra power, and it can even be matched to a manual transmission for the handful of large sedan buyers who prefer rowing their own gears.

Unlike the Camry, the Accord’s blend of ride quality and handling poise made the car feel smaller and lighter than it actually is. It can be as rewarding to drive as the Mazda, but can feel as smooth and relaxed as the Toyota. Honda simply nailed it here.

End of the day, Honda created what we think will be the benchmark midsize sedan for years to come. It probably won’t reverse the current SUV trend, but consumers should know that they’ll be missing out on an excellent car that offers the best roundup of comfort, fuel economy, refinement and technology.

Crystal Ball

There isn’t much more that needs to be said for now, as we won’t see many significant changes in the midsize sedan category in the coming year or two. A new generation of the Nissan Altima should be revealed in 2018, the Volkswagen Passat received a new base engine, but no other changes, while the Kia Optima, Ford Fusion, Subaru Legacy and Chevrolet Malibu will likely soldier on for a couple of years with minor updates.

As for Hybrids, we still have choice between the Malibu, the Camry, the Sonata, the Optima and the Fusion. A redesigned Accord Hybrid should arrive this year as well. Only the Fusion, the Sonata and the Optima offer plug-in hybrid powertrains.

So unless Nissan hits a home run with the new Altima, the Honda Accord should remain the top dog among non-hybrid midsize sedans for a while.

FINAL SCORING

Year2018201820172018
MakeHondaHyundaiMazdaToyota
ModelAccordSonataMazda6Camry
DESIGN/STYLE
Exterior/2016.013.516.314.0
Interior/2015.514.314.515.8
Total/4031.527.830.829.8
BODY/CABIN
Exerior finish/106.37.57.47.3
Interior finish/108.07.57.58.2
Dashboard/107.97.57.07.4
Equipment/108.08.17.37.6
Trunk/2017.016.815.516.0
Storage/2016.014.513.514.5
Total/8063.161.958.160.9
COMFORT / ERGONOMICS
Driver's seat/2017.015.816.015.3
Front pass. seat/2017.016.715.315.3
Rear seats/2015.515.315.013.8
Ergonomics/2016.315.314.014.5
Infotainment/3026.322.520.619.5
Sound insulation/2014.013.013.516.5
Total/130106.098.494.594.8
DRIVE
Handling/1512.810.111.911.4
Engine/1512.411.39.612.9
Steering/1512.410.711.611.3
Brakes/1511.611.411.310.5
Transmission/1512.410.111.811.1
Ride quality/1511.610.311.312.2
Total/9073.163.967.469.4
SAFETY
Visibility/2014.815.013.814.5
Driving aids/2015.516.012.515.0
Total/4030.331.026.329.5
EDITORS' CHOICE
Average/5049364045
TOTAL/500401.5370.9365.5376.1
RANK1342

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS

Year

2018201820172018
MakeHondaHyundaiMazdaToyota
ModelAccord TouringSonata Sport 2.0TMazda6 GTCamry XSE V6
Wheelbase (mm)28302805

2830

2825
Length (mm)4882485548654895
Width (mm)1906186518401840
Height (mm)1450146514501445
Curb weight (kg)1497164014681620
Passenger capacity5555
Interior volume (litres)2910300428242812
Trunk volume (litres)473462419427
EngineTurbocharged L4Turbocharged L4L4V6
Displacement (litres)1.52.02.53.5
Maximum power (hp @ rpm)192 @ 5500245 @ 6000184 @ 5700301 @ 6600
Maximum torque (lb.-ft. @ rpm)192 @ 1600 - 5000260 @ 1350 - 4000185 @ 3250267 @ 4700
Required fuelregularregularregularregular
TransmissionCVT automatic8-speed automatic6-speed manual8-speed automatic
DrivetrainFront-wheel driveFront-wheel driveFront-wheel driveFront-wheel drive
Front suspensionInd., strutsInd., strutsInd., strutsInd., struts
Rear suspensionInd., multilinkInd., multilinkInd., multilinkInd., double wishbone
Front brakesDiscDiscDiscDisc
Rear brakesDiscDiscDiscDisc
Tires235/40R19P235/45R18225/45R19P235/40R19
SteeringRack-and-pinion, electric assistRack-and-pinion, electric assistRack-and-pinion, electric ass.Rack-and-pinion, electric ass.
Turning diameter (m)11.610.911.210.8
Fuel tank (litres)56.070.062.060.6
Acceleration 0-100 km/h (sec)8.26.79.16.2
Accel. 1/4 mile (sec @ km/h)15.9 @ 14314.8 @ 15316.3 @ 14214.4 @ 159
Acceleration 80 to 120 km/h (sec)5.95.06.55.0
Braking 100-0 km/h (m)40404343 (winter tires)
City/Hwy/Comb NRCan fuel cons. (L/100 km)8.2 / 6.8 / 7.610.4 / 7.4 / 9.19.8 / 6.9 / 8.410.5 / 7.1 / 9.0
Observed fuel economy (L/100 km)9.89.08.413.7
Base / maximum MSRP$26,490 / $39,090$24,799 / $43,999$24,695 / $37,095$26,590 / $41,190
As-tested price$35,790$36,999$33,195$39,890
Freight and delivery charges$1,683$1,805$1,795$1,715
Warranty (comprehensive / powertrain)3/60 (C), 5/100 (P)5/100 (C), 5/100 (P)3/Unl. (C), 5/Unl. (P)3/60 (C), 5/100 (P)

The State of Accord and Camry: All New at the Same Time for the First Time Ever .
The State of Accord and Camry: All New at the Same Time for the First Time EverThe Accord and Camry assimilated into American culture so thoroughly that they have long ceased being foreign at all. They’re largely engineered here, built here, and have topped the sales charts here for so long that millennials, post-millennials, and post-post-millennials don’t consider them anything but America’s most ubiquitous cars. Forget all the other minnows in the sedan mainstream. The Accord and the Camry are the big fish; the rest are swimming hard in their wake. And now, for the first time in the Accord’s 42 years and the Camry’s 35, they’re both all new at the same moment.

Source: http://ca.pressfrom.com/autos/reviews/-61020-midsize-sedan-comparison-test-camry-sonata-accord-and-mazda6/

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!