Canada Laura Babcock murder trial: What happens if Dellen Millard testifies?

14:23  13 november  2017
14:23  13 november  2017 Source:   CBC

Dellen Millard promised in text to 'hurt' Laura Babcock

  Dellen Millard promised in text to 'hurt' Laura Babcock Dellen Millard promised in text to 'hurt' Laura BabcockJim Falconer, a recently retired detective sergeant from the Ontario Provincial Police's technical crimes unit, is testifying in the trial of Dellen Millard and Mark Smich, who are charged with first-degree murder in the presumed death of Laura Babcock, whose body has not been found.

Laura Babcock murder trial : Officer who searched Dellen Millard 's home testifies . "I think what would happen [here] is Millard would get up on the stand and be sworn, and would just be invited to give his evidence in the form of a speech."

Dellen Millard questions Laura Babcock 's father at murder trial . Accused killer Dellen Millard questions ex-boyfriend of Laura Babcock . Friend testifies in Babcock trial that accused admitted to 'torching' woman's body and disposing of it.

Laura Babcock murder trial: What happens if Dellen Millard testifies?: Dellen Millard, 32, is acting as his own lawyer at the Laura Babcock murder trial, a very unusual situation in such severe charges. (Toronto Police Service)<br />© Toronto Police Service Dellen Millard, 32, is acting as his own lawyer at the Laura Babcock murder trial, a very unusual situation in such severe charges. (Toronto Police Service)

For weeks now, an exceptionally rare spectacle has been unfolding inside a Toronto courtroom.

Dellen Millard, charged with first-degree murder in the death of 23-year-old Toronto woman Laura Babcock, is representing himself — something that is almost unheard of in Canada on such severe charges.

He's been trying to do all the things a defence lawyer would normally do, like cross-examining witnesses, entering evidence and making legal arguments before Justice Michael Code in Ontario Superior Court.

Forensic officer to testify at Babcock trial

  Forensic officer to testify at Babcock trial TORONTO - The Crown's star witness at a murder trial in the case of a woman who vanished five years ago is expected to delve deep into his forensic analysis of computers seized from the home of one of the accused. Retired Ontario Provincial Police Det. Sgt. Jim Falconer will continue to go through a massive trove of data from three computers found at Dellen Millard's home. Millard, 32, of Toronto and Mark Smich, 30 of Oakville, Ont., have pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder in the presumed death of Laura Babcock, 23.

Dellen Millard received a warning Tuesday from the judge overseeing his first-degree murder trial Dellen Millard , centre, questioned Laura Babcock 's former boyfriend Shawn Lerner in court on Tuesday. But Lerner did testify about one person he spoke with during that search: Dellen Millard .

Burning objects seen in photo taken of the inside an incinerator belonging to accused killer Dellen Millard look like human bones, according to an expert in bones and burned remains who testified today at the Laura Babcock murder trial in Toronto.

But as the Crown's case against the 32-year-old Toronto man and his co-accused Mark Smich, 30, of Oakville, Ont., continues, a question looms.

What happens if Millard wants to testify?

Has the right to testify

It's his right as an accused person to sit in the witness box and give his version of events if he so chooses. Usually, that would happen through what's called "examination in chief," where a defence lawyer asks their client questions to allow them to give their version of an event.

An amicus is also sometimes appointed by a judge to assist a self-represented defendant, and that person could theoretically examine Millard — but that hasn't happened in this case so far.

This odd perfect storm has created an incredibly unique set of circumstances, said Blair Crew, review counsel at the University of Ottawa Community Legal Clinic.

Uncle denies Millard's story on pet cremation biz

  Uncle denies Millard's story on pet cremation biz Uncle denies Millard's story on pet cremation bizBut that uncle, veterinarian Robert Burns, emphatically told jurors at Dellen Millard's trial that his nephew never asked him to launch such a business, calling the idea "absurd.

Detectives who seized evidence during the search for Laura Babcock , who disappeared in July 2012, testified Friday at the Toronto murder trial of Dellen Millard and Mark Smich. Co-accused Dellen Millard and Mark Smich have pleaded not guilty to 1st-degree murder .

Laura Babcock Murder : Lover Dellen Millard Burned Missing Woman's Body In Incinerator, Prosecutors Charge. Burned Alive: Mississippi Teen Cheerleader Murder Case Court Trial Begins, Witnesses Recall Her Horrific Death.

"A ... situation where an accused has no lawyer, has chosen to represent himself and nobody has been appointed to assist is a very rare coming together of events that you would rarely see in first-degree murder trials," Crew told CBC News.

Millard likely to 'tell his story' if he's in the witness box

What would likely happen if Millard chose to testify, Crew said, is that the judge would allow him to sit in the witness box and just give his own testimony "more in a narrative fashion instead of the standard question and answer format that you would see if he did have counsel."

Toronto defence lawyer Ingrid Grant says she has encountered a situation like this once before in court, though not on something as severe as a first-degree murder charge.

"In that case, [the accused] said he wanted testify, he got up on the stand, he was sworn, and then he was invited to just give his evidence, to tell his story, to tell the jury whatever he wanted to tell them within the bounds of what's relevant," Grant said.

Lost Laura Babcock was a kernel without a husk: Mallick

  Lost Laura Babcock was a kernel without a husk: Mallick Lost Laura Babcock was a kernel without a husk: Mallick On a fine Toronto night in the final week of June 2012, did you see a young woman stop off in a cab, with luggage and a little white Maltese — a lady with a dog — and settle in for the night on a park bench near your house?

Dellen Millard and Mark Smich have been charged with her murder . (Facebook). Friends have testified over the last week that Babcock , an intelligent University of Toronto graduate, was both Laura Babcock murder trial : Former detective tells jury what was found on seized electronic devices.

Dellen Millard tells murder trial he didn't care about girlfriend's feud with Laura Babcock . Millard text calls his promise to hurt Laura Babcock a ‘sinister insinuation’: murder trial . Millard and his girlfriend, Christina Noudga, sent messages back and forth discussing Babcock at length a few

"I think what would happen [here] is Millard would get up on the stand and be sworn, and would just be invited to give his evidence in the form of a speech."

There isn't a lot of precedent in Canada for these types of situations, as most people charged with first-degree murder get a lawyer.

Bizarre American case

There is, however, one famous case out of the U.S. — that of convicted rapist and serial killer Rodney Alcala , known as "The Dating Game Killer," because of his appearance on the TV game show back in the 1970s.

Alcala acted as his own lawyer in a 2010 murder trial, and chose to testify. For hours on the stand, he acted both as lawyer and witness, asking himself questions in a deep voice in the third person, and then answering them, as if he was having a conversation with himself.

"That really did happen, in a real case … though I don't think that would actually happen here," Grant said.

What this unique situation in the Babcock case would likely also mean, Crew said, is an increased role for the judge in making sure any testimony coming from Millard is admissible and appropriate.

Laura Babcock murder trial: These are the people who tried to help in the days before her disappearance

  Laura Babcock murder trial: These are the people who tried to help in the days before her disappearance The ongoing trial into the presumed murder of Toronto's Laura Babcock has heard from a number of her close friends. Many told the jury how they offered her a sympathetic ear or place to stay. These are some of their stories.If you believe the Crown's theory, Babcock was killed by Dellen Millard, 32, of Toronto, and his best friend Mark Smich, 30 of Oakville, Ont.

Dellen Millard , 32, is acting as his own lawyer at the Laura Babcock murder trial . Babcock wasn't happy. "She stomped around a lot," Trevors testified . Eventually they agreed Trevors would drive Babcock home, to the home of her parents in Etobicoke.

In the months before she vanished, Laura Babcock was using hard drugs, working as an escort and actively seeking treatment for her mental health issues, the trial of two men accused of The Crown alleges that Dellen Millard , 32, of Toronto, and Mark Smich, 30, of Oakville, Ont., murdered the

But from a legal perspective, does it make sense for Millard to choose to get up in the witness box and testify?

Risky strategy

"There's always a risk that an accused who acts as his own counsel and who chooses to take the stand is going to come across to the jury as being arrogant in thinking he can do this, or thinking this charge is just very minor and I, as an amateur, can be my own lawyer," Crew said.

"I don't think that that level of confidence or arrogance would necessarily play well in front of a jury."

The Babcock case resumes on Tuesday morning, when Millard will cross-examine forensic anthropologist Dr. Tracy Rogers about her testimony.

Rogers told the court on Friday afternoon that burning objects seen in photo taken of the inside an incinerator belonging to Millard look like human bones.

adam.carter@cbc.ca

Gruesome testimony, paltry pay: MPs to study jurors' mental health, financial needs .
Next week MPs will begin a groundbreaking study of the impact of jury duty on mental health to determine what specialized services, funding and new policies are needed.The job comes with little compensation and few supports, and MPs on the justice committee say that needs to change.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!