Canada Memo to ethics czar: Don’t gag MPs or media

13:41  11 february  2018
13:41  11 february  2018 Source:   thestar.com

Release of disputed GOP memo on FBI surveillance unleashes waves of recrimination

  Release of disputed GOP memo on FBI surveillance unleashes waves of recrimination The document is at the center of a fight between the FBI, the White House and Republican lawmakers.(Video provided by Reuters)

So it was alarming to hear that in his effort to be “tougher” than his predecessor, Canada’s new Ethics Commissioner, Mario Dion, is seeking to gag MPs and impose publication bans. But then he raised concerns that MPs can tell the media when they’ve filed a complaint and the press can report on it.

An editorial from the Toronto Star, published Feb. 11: Two of the greatest bulwarks of a democracy are freedom of expression and a free press. So it was alarming to hear that in his effort to be “tougher” than his predecessor, Canada’s new Ethics Commissioner, Mario Dion

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

Ethics Commissioner Mario Dion must avoid attempting to trample on charter rights in his new job.© Adrian Wyld Ethics Commissioner Mario Dion must avoid attempting to trample on charter rights in his new job.

Two of the greatest bulwarks of a democracy are freedom of expression and a free press.

So it was alarming to hear that in his effort to be “tougher” than his predecessor, Canada’s new Ethics Commissioner, Mario Dion, is seeking to gag MPs and impose publication bans.

Dion made the disturbing remarks during an appearance last week before a Commons committee while discussing how he believed that ethics investigations should be conducted in private.

Nassar accuser: 'Larry was a master manipulator'

  Nassar accuser: 'Larry was a master manipulator' Nassar accuser: 'Larry was a master manipulator'More women and girls are giving victim statements in a Michigan courtroom in a third sentencing hearing for Larry Nassar, the disgraced former gymnastics doctor who has pleaded guilty to molesting people under the guise of medical treatment.

Former ethics czar to the Obama administration Norm Eisen talks to CNN's John Berman about EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt's controversies, including reports

In the United States, the informal political term " czar " or "tsar" is employed in media and popular usage to refer to high-level officials who oversee a particular policy. There have never been any U.S. government offices with the title " czar "

There’s nothing wrong with that. But then he raised concerns that MPs can tell the media when they’ve filed a complaint and the press can report on it. That, he said, “pollutes the environment within which we have to do our examination.”

To prevent that from happening he suggested he should have the power to issue confidentiality orders to prevent MPs from informing the public about a complaint and stop the media from reporting on an investigation, no matter who their source was for the information in the first place.

Those are very dangerous ideas, indeed, and Dion should immediately drop them from his otherwise sensible proposed reforms on ethics issues.

While the former career civil servant complained that it “complicates our lives as investigators when people start to know something is under investigation,” he better get used to it.

Trump says memo release 'totally vindicates' him in Russia probe

  Trump says memo release 'totally vindicates' him in Russia probe Trump says memo release 'totally vindicates' him in Russia probe"This memo totally vindicates 'Trump' in probe. But the Russian Witch Hunt goes on and on," Trump tweeted. "Their was no Collusion and there was no Obstruction (the word now used because, after one year of looking endlessly and finding NOTHING, collusion is dead).

The new ethics commissioner, Mario Dion, has suggested he would like to prevent MPs from informing the media when they have filed a complaint with his office and stop the media from reporting on an

POLICING THE USA: A look at race, justice, and media . Norman Eisen, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and chairman of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, was President Obama's ethics czar from 2009 to 2011.

Transparency can be messy, but it is vital to a democracy.

Indeed, freedoms of the press and expression are both protected by Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which states these rights are “subject only to such reasonable limits prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.”

Dion’s worries about complications hardly fit that bill.

And as Conservative MP and former journalist Peter Kent pointed out, Dion’s suggestion also ignores the fact that the ethics commissioner sometimes undertakes investigations because of issues that are reported in the media in the first place.

“I think protections of free speech, journalistic practice, need to be defended and balanced,” Kent said.

And so they should be.

Despite his stumbling on free speech and media rights, Dion’s appearance before the committee indicated that he is on the right track with other ideas that are actually within his purview.

Patrick Brown likely ‘inflated’ membership numbers — by 70,000, says Ontario PC official

  Patrick Brown likely ‘inflated’ membership numbers — by 70,000, says Ontario PC official But to further muddy the waters, a party executive member says he reviewed the memberships - and there are more than Brown saidThe number dwarfed that of the governing Liberals, and was more “than we’ve ever had before,” Brown boasted at the time.

'We are beyond Watergate': George W. Bush's ethics czar says there is more 'abuse of power' evidence against Trump than there was against Nixon. Paris Jackson is pictured for the FIRST time since the death of grandfather Joe Jackson after sharing a touching tribute on social media .

Former Obama Ethics Czar Norm Eisen told Anderson Cooper that Rudy Giuliani‘s recent appearances on Fox News “exposed” Trump to a “felony charge of filing false presidential financial statements” as well as obstruction of justice Dershowitz immediately pushed back. “But Norm, don ’ t give me credit.

For example, he said he would seek the right to impose substantial fines in the range of $25,000 on MPs for ethics breaches.

This is a sensible suggestion that would go a fair way to restoring public trust in government. That was undermined when Dion’s predecessor, Mary Dawson, ruled that the prime minister’s holiday vacation on the Aga Khan’s private island was illegal, but there were no consequences beyond public embarrassment.

Dion also rightly suggested doing away with a clause in the conflict-of-interest law that allows public office holders to accept gifts from friends. That was the defence the prime minister invoked for accepting the Aga Khan’s invitation.

And Dion wisely repeated his promise to advocate for a tougher conflict-of-interest law to close what the opposition now calls the “Bill Morneau loophole.”

Morneau was allowed, by law and purportedly on the advice of the then ethics commissioner, to maintain control over a large stake in his former company, even as he ran the country’s finances. It is established procedure, but not a requirement, for ministers to place their holdings in a blind trust as a way of avoiding conflicts of interest, real or perceived. That Morneau was not required to do this is concerning. The loophole should be closed.

Overall, Dion is on the right track in his new role of holding MPs accountable for any ethics violations. But he must avoid trampling on charter freedoms to do so. It should go without saying that any curtailment of free speech and freedom of the press should be out of bounds for an ethics commissioner.

Mother Slams Elton John After 5-Year-Old Daughter’s Face Scratched By Star’s Dog During Play Date .
Mother Slams Elton John After 5-Year-Old Daughter’s Face Scratched By Star’s Dog During Play DateTwo years later, a British woman is still fuming after her daughter was bitten by one of Elton John's dogs during a play date with his children.

Source: http://ca.pressfrom.com/news/canada/-63116-memo-to-ethics-czar-don-t-gag-mps-or-media/

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
This is interesting!