Canada Canada can't say where its crime guns are coming from

14:51  10 august  2018
14:51  10 august  2018 Source:   cbc.ca

Canadians could face prison time for making 3D-printed guns: officials

  Canadians could face prison time for making 3D-printed guns: officials Canadians who try to make the 3D-printed 'Liberator' handgun without a licence will face prison time if convicted, officials said ahead of the release of the plans online.Canadians who make their own 3D-printed guns without a licence will face mandatory prison time if convicted, the federal government says.

(CBC). "With so many crime guns coming from legitimate domestic sources, we need effective firearm measures," he tweeted. The need for better numbers. It ' s one of the few subjects on which gun owners and gun control advocates can agree: Canada needs better gun data.

A new report from the Center for American Progress analyzed data from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) and found that 70% of the crime guns recovered and traced in Mexico, and 98% of crime guns in Canada originate in the U.S.

a hand holding a gun: There's a lack of consistent data on the origin of guns used in crime in Canada - and no national effort to collect accurate numbers. © Robert Short/CBC There's a lack of consistent data on the origin of guns used in crime in Canada - and no national effort to collect accurate numbers.

"It is a fact that the majority of gun-related crimes in our communities are committed with guns that are domestically-sourced," RCMP Inspector Chris McBryan told the Vancouver Sun two years ago.

Insp. McBryan was speaking as head of the Western Canada division of the National Weapons Enforcement Support Team (NWEST) of the Canadian Firearms Program (CFP).

But when CBC News contacted the CFP and asked for the data behind his categorical statement, the RCMP replied that no such data exists.

NDP demands leeway for cities to ban handguns

  NDP demands leeway for cities to ban handguns OTTAWA - Federal NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh is formally asking the prime minister to immediately give cities the leeway to ban handguns. In a lengthy letter to Justin Trudeau outlining a long-term approach to tackling crime, Singh says more policing is not a solution to gun violence in cities because it amplifies distrust between communities. Instead, he says allowing cities to ban handguns would help municipal authorities deal with the fact that many gun crimes are committed with legal guns.Singh also wants the government to dramatically speed up earmarked funding to quash gang violence.© Provided by thecanadianpress.

America is an exceptional country when it comes to guns . 7) America is an outlier when it comes to gun deaths, but not overall crime . Parkland shooting galvanized teen gun control activists across the country. These 4 products say everything about America’s gun problem.

Inside Brent Nicholson's house, guns were everywhere: rifles and shotguns piled in the living room, halls and bedrooms; handguns littering tables and countertops. The map below shows which states these border-crossing crime guns came from .

"Inspector McBryan's statement would have been based on information available to him at that time; however, this information would not have provided a complete, national picture of the sources of crime guns, as no such data exists," says a statement from the RCMP.

"Currently, there is no national repository for this type of information in Canada. The Canadian Firearms Program does not collect or track national statistics with regard to the origin of crime guns," said Sgt. Marie Damian.

Lots of speculation, few facts

Conservative Larry Maguire may have thought his status as a member of Parliament could get him better answers, so he put his question about the national origin of seized guns on the order paper.

He received a detailed accounting of seizures from 2015 to 2017 broken down by year, by province, by firearms class and by registration status. But to his main question about whether the guns were sourced in Canada or smuggled from the U.S., he got this reply: "The Canadian Firearms Information System does not collect the requested information."

Toronto police break up cocaine, heroin distribution ring in Project Switch

  Toronto police break up cocaine, heroin distribution ring in Project Switch Toronto police unveiled a significant haul of drugs and several guns seized as part of an months-long investigation into a cocaine and heroin distribution ring, dubbed Project Switch, on Thursday. According to Acting Inspector Steve Watts, with Toronto police's drug unit, a group made up of two distinct factions were importing 'large quantities' of the drugs from the U.S. in tractor trailers.

So where does this claim of more domestically sourced guns come from ? Law enforcement has been instructed to count a crime gun as domestic if they can ' t trace the origin. Its a UN agenda. Canada and the US are still strongholds for gun ownership.

US & Canada . Nearly 20% came from Indiana, where gun laws have made it relatively easy to obtain illegal weapons. In fact, the University of Chicago Crime Lab found a 43% reduction in violent crime arrests for youths who obtained eight-week, part-time employment through its One Summer

Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale told a guns and gangs summit in Ottawa this year that more and more guns used in crimes in Canada were coming from within the country.

a close up of a piece of paper: This statistic is from figures compiled by the Provincial Weapons Enforcement Unit of the Ontario Provincial Police. © CBC This statistic is from figures compiled by the Provincial Weapons Enforcement Unit of the Ontario Provincial Police.

"With so many crime guns coming from legitimate domestic sources, we need effective firearm measures," he tweeted.

But at the same summit, Lynn Barr-Telford, director-general in charge of justice surveys at Statistics Canada, lamented the "gaps" in her department's data.

"We don't know the origin of firearms involved in gun crime in Canada," she said.

The need for better numbers

It's one of the few subjects on which gun owners and gun control advocates can agree: Canada needs better gun data.

"I remember working on training programs with the national weapons enforcement support team to actually communicate to police why it was important to trace firearms," said Wendy Cukier of the Coalition for Gun Control.

Police charge two men with running illegal cannabis grow-op at Health Canada licensed facility north of Toronto

  Police charge two men with running illegal cannabis grow-op at Health Canada licensed facility north of Toronto Two Quebec men have been charged with running an illegal cannabis grow-op in King Township after York Regional Police seized 288 kilograms of harvested cannabis and more than 4,000 plants, which police say have an estimated street value of $6.5 million. There were three Health Canada licenses for the facility, which allowed for each license holder or a designate to grow 875 plants on their behalf for medical purposes, but the operation at the site far exceed this, police said.

What does this mean for Canada ’s gun laws? In the immediate aftermath of the San Bernardino shootings, neither the Canadian government nor its federal opponents had much to say on America’s chronic problem with gun crime .

Eugenio Weigend, who co-authored the report, said it was intended to counter a "narrative of President Trump, that we need to secure the border because crime is coming from Mexico, from the Central American countries."

"You can imagine, police often are short-staffed and have limited resources. They're working on solving a murder investigation — focusing on tracing the source of the firearm may or may not be viewed as critical to prosecuting that particular crime.

"And so, typically, tracing firearms has not been a top priority of police agencies across the country."

Cukier said she believes there is convincing anecdotal evidence from police forces to support the idea that more crime guns are coming from within the country.

Former Mountie and gun-rights advocate Dennis Young disagrees with that conclusion — but he said he'd also like to see better tracking.

"Accurate statistics should be collected by the Canadian Firearms Centre, and they're not," he said. "And those statistics should be verified and reported by Statistics Canada, and they're not."

Breaking and entering

Goodale does appear to be able to point to one data set that could support his conclusions: the rise in break-and-enters targeting firearms.

Entering a home or business to steal a gun is a very serious offence that carries a maximum sentence of life in prison — and yet, it's happening more frequently, says Public Safety Canada.

Tory urges Trudeau to prevent repeat gun offenders from getting bail

  Tory urges Trudeau to prevent repeat gun offenders from getting bail Toronto Mayor John Tory has outlined his vision for gun violence prevention in a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. Tory is calling on Ottawa to toughen bail rules, crack down on trafficking and ban handgun sales inside city limits. The request is one of several made by Tory in an Aug. 3 letter to the prime minister that outlines the mayor's vision for gun violence prevention.

Police researchers say that most illegal guns come from nearby states like Indiana and Iowa after being stolen or resold by their original owners, according to a Tuesday report from the Chicago Sun Times.

In a letter to Khan, Steve O’Connell, the Conservative member who leads the committee, called for more research into where guns come from and Drug dealing and gang activity were identified as the main drivers of gun crime , with gangs said to account for nearly half of all offences where lethal

Goodale made the point graphically during the guns and gangs summit in Ottawa this spring:

a screenshot of a cell phone: Public Safety Minster Ralph Goodale tweeted this graphic out after hosting the a summit on gun and gang violence in Ottawa in March. © Twitter Public Safety Minster Ralph Goodale tweeted this graphic out after hosting the a summit on gun and gang violence in Ottawa in March.

But a closer look at Statistics Canada figures raises questions about this argument.

"Between 2013 and 2016 ... break-ins for the purpose of stealing firearms went up by 56 per cent," Goodale wrote in an op-ed. That statement is supported by the statistics.

But that statement — like the graph that accompanies Goodale's tweet — fails to capture the fact that, last year, the number of break-ins involving the theft of firearms fell again, by more than 10 per cent, leaving it below the levels of the previous two years.

And statisticians have questioned Public Safety's repeated use of 2013 as a baseline for its year-over-year comparisons, given that 2013 saw the lowest rate of criminal homicides in a half-century, and the lowest rate of fatal shootings ever recorded by Statistics Canada.

'Firearm-related crime'

The problems with Canada's gun statistics don't end with the failure to compile a national database on gun traces. Even the definition of what constitutes a "crime gun" or a "firearm-related violent crime" is problematic.

Medicine Hat man charged with inciting hatred in public

  Medicine Hat man charged with inciting hatred in public Police were called by a local business on July 31 after a man displayed money stamped with an anti-Semitic message. A Medicine Hat, Alta., man is facing charges of inciting hatred in public after complaints from a local business about someone displaying money stamped with When police arrested the man on July 31, a search of the suspect's backpack turned up several $5 and $20 bills that had been stamped with hateful markings directed toward Jewish people.

Police studies in Canada estimated that 2-16% of guns used in crimes were stolen from legal owners and thus potentially in the registry. The bulk of the guns , Canadian officials concluded, were unregistered weapons imported illegally from the U.S. by criminal gangs.

Should US control its gun laws or should Canada be better at ensuring they dont get smuggled in? As far as where Canada 's guns are coming from , as long as there is a demand, there will be guns . Say they just hate you ? 7, 8 hour work days consecutively in Massachusetts?

Most Canadians might assume that a "crime gun" is a gun that has been used in a crime — to shoot, rob or threaten another person. They might assume that a "firearm-related violent crime" is a crime in which a gun has been used, or at least brandished.

Neither assumption is true. As one StatsCan report ( Firearms and Violent Crime in Canada, 2016 ) points out, "for an offence to be considered firearm-related, a firearm need only be present during the commission of the offence, not necessarily used."

Imagine a fist fight between two people in a home: the police are called and, after arresting the guilty parties, they notice a gun cabinet and remove a legally-owned rifle from the home. That fist fight will be recorded as a "firearm-related violent crime."

Found and abandoned

The RCMP's definition of a "crime gun" is also broader than the one used by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms in the U.S. It covers not only guns used (or suspected of having been used) in crimes, but also guns that were illegally acquired or modified by having the barrel cut or the serial number altered, or guns that were "found" or "abandoned."

Most problematic are the categories of "found" guns and illegal acquisition. Say a lawful firearms owner dies, leaving behind a hunting rifle that his widow has no lawful authority to possess. She surrenders it to police; the gun probably isn't a threat to public safety, but it could still be listed as a "crime gun."

It just obscures the reality of what a crime gun is.

- Gun-rights advocate Dennis Young on the gaps in Canada's firearms statistics

Ford once again presses Tory for action on gun violence in new letter

  Ford once again presses Tory for action on gun violence in new letter Ford once again presses Tory for action on gun violence in new letter In his latest letter to Tory, Ford reiterated the provincial government's investment of $25 million in funding, which will help in providing tools and resources to combat gun violence, but added that more needs to be done.

Where do the guns come from ? The National Crime Agency (NCA) in the UK says blank-firing and deactivated guns are bought legally by organised crime gangs in Europe who then "reactivate" them - often by removing an obstruction from the barrel - and sell them in the criminal market.

Other high-income countries have much stronger gun laws than we have. They vary from incredibly draconian gun restrictions in countries such as England and Japan, where almost nobody has guns , to places like Canada , where a fair amount of people own guns .

Likewise, if a hunter buys a shotgun at a gun show when his license is expired, he's acquired that gun illegally; if it's subsequently seized by police, it becomes a "crime gun." The same designation likely awaits the rusty old rifle discovered in the attic above the barn, even though it may have been forgotten for decades.

Blending those types of firearms with semi-automatic handguns recovered at murder scenes seems likely to reduce the usefulness of the statistics, and of any conclusions gleaned from them.

Gun owners say the breadth of that "crime gun" category risks inflating the number of true crime guns originating in Canada.

"These aren't people that have done anything wrong other than run afoul of red tape that's invented by Ottawa," said Young. "It just obscures the reality of what a crime gun is."

Seized guns rarely have smoking barrels

Statistics compiled by the RCMP's Canadian Firearms Program on seizures of "crime guns" in Western Canada in 2014 suggest that few such weapons are linked to specific violent incidents.

Of 1,140 "crime guns" seized in B.C., Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, NWT and Yukon that year, only 150 were recovered following specific violent offences, including "disturbance" and "uttering threats."

A far larger number were seized by police executing warrants, traffic stops or Mental Health Act interventions, or were listed as "abandoned/found."

CBSA displays guns and magazines it has seized. © Denis Dossmann/CBC CBSA displays guns and magazines it has seized.

And "crime guns" only make up a subset of the total number of guns seized by police in Canada.

The category of "seized" guns includes large numbers of firearms seized for what might be called administrative offences.

"Examples of such seizures include lapsed registration, improper storage, failure to renew a license and licenses revoked," said Sgt. Damian.

Some of those offences — particularly improper storage and license revocation — do have public safety implications. But those guns probably are still of less concern to the public than the semi-automatic handguns that are already in criminal hands.

It seems the one safe conclusion that can be drawn from Canada's available gun data is that we'd be better off if we had more of it.

Witton Luu, 25, sentenced in organized crime drug busts, dies in prison .
Witton Luu, 25, sentenced in organized crime drug busts, dies in prisonWitton Luu, 25, died at the Joyceville medium security prison near Kingston last Wednesday.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!