Money Tim Hortons getting ‘dragged through the mud’ as franchise fight escalates — and the iconic brand isn’t doing anything to stop it

05:05  12 january  2018
05:05  12 january  2018 Source:   financialpost.com

By the numbers: How much will the minimum wage hike cost Tim Hortons?

  By the numbers: How much will the minimum wage hike cost Tim Hortons? The Great White North Franchisee Association says the minimum wage increase will cost the average Tim Hortons franchise $243,889.10 a year Here’s a closer look at the numbers provided by the association, which says on its website it represents 50 per cent of the Tim Hortons chain in Canada. The figure is based on a minimum wage increase of $2.40 an hour The calculation assumes the $2.40 increase will be applied to every worker’s salary. Only employees who were making the previous minimum wage, $11.60 an hour, are legally entitled to the new rate, $14. Some businesses have said the higher rate will inflate their entire payroll because they want to maintain pay differentials between newer hires and more senior staff. The $2.40 rate is bumped up to $3.35 an hour when other costs are factored in. GWNFA says this figure includes Canadian Pension Plan, Employment Insurance, Employee Health tax, workers’ compensation premiums, training costs, sick leave, and increased vacation pay. Increased vacation pay introduced by Bill 148 will only impact workers who have been with a company for five years or more. They will now be entitled to three weeks leave. Average number of employees at a Tim Hortons store: 35 Average increased cost for one full-time employee: $6,968.26 Divided by the hourly cost increase (of $3.35) per employee and a 52-week year, this figure suggests Tim Hortons employees work a 40-hour week.

TORONTO — While the ugly fight between Tim Hortons and its franchisees appears to be far from over, a clear loser has emerged from the battle — Canada’s iconic coffee brand . What’s puzzling, say marketing and communications experts

"Time is money! How quickly can I have a professional video for my business?" " Tim Hortons getting ' dragged through the mud ' and iconic brand isn ' t doing anything to stop it " (Financial Post) - Highlights - "Timac Agro Lietuva" žengia kartu su pasaulinėmis inovacijomis.

0111timhortons: The iconic Tim Hortons brand has been under seige after more than a week of a public outcry from its own Tim Hortons restaurant owners, their aggrieved employees and consumers.© The iconic Tim Hortons brand has been under seige after more than a week of a public outcry from its... The iconic Tim Hortons brand has been under seige after more than a week of a public outcry from its own Tim Hortons restaurant owners, their aggrieved employees and consumers. TORONTO — While the ugly fight between Tim Hortons and its franchisees appears to be far from over, a clear loser has emerged from the battle — Canada’s iconic coffee brand.

What’s puzzling, say marketing and communications experts, is why the country’s biggest quick-service restaurant chain is not in full-blown damage-control mode after more than a week of a public outcry from its own Tim Hortons restaurant owners, their aggrieved employees and consumers.

The hypocrisy of a Tim Hortons: a business built on coffee breaks

  The hypocrisy of a Tim Hortons: a business built on coffee breaks If all Canadians lost their paid breaks, like some workers at a Tim Hortons in Ontario, what would be left of the once iconic company?MCD

Tim Hortons getting ‘ dragged through the mud ’ and iconic brand isn ’ t doing anything to stop it . Trump's 'submission' strategy failed so expect NAFTA talks to drag on. Argentina's woes 'may be tip of the iceberg' of an even bigger crisis for world economy.

1 In 3 Tim Hortons Customers Say Their Opinion Of The Chain Is Worsening: Angus Reid Does your Switch look bad on a 4K TV? Read this! Will I ever feel anything for my husband? Ashleigh Banfield Rips Aziz Ansari Accuser, Calls Allegations 'Reckless and Hollow' Can we stop commenting

Quotes in the article

McDonald's Corp

MCD

Patrons boycott Tim's over employee treatment

  Patrons boycott Tim's over employee treatment Patrons boycott Tim's over employee treatment"No one has ever seen me without a Tim Hortons cup in my hand," said the in-house trade union counsel.

Through franchise partnership with Dubai-based Apparel Group, Tim Hortons entered the United Tim Hortons ' advertising slogans have included "You've Always Got Time for Tim Hortons " and Canadian Business magazine has named Tim Hortons as the best-managed brand in Canada in

Related Stories. Tim Hortons getting ' dragged through the mud ' and iconic brand isn ' t doing anything to stop it . Ontario’s minimum wage hike will cost the average Tim Hortons franchisee 3,889 this year.

173.39
-0.12
-0.07%
S&P/TSX Composite

0000

16,286.94
+38.99
+0.24%
S&P/TSX Venture Composite

ISPVX

889.51
-21.33
-2.34%
S&P TSX 60

TSP60

966.66
+2.96
+0.31%

Tim Hortons’ corporate Twitter and Facebook profiles, normally home to the coffee and doughnut chain’s daily photo and message postings, have not been updated since the New Year, where the most recent postings have piled up a stack of condemnatory comments from the public.

“Tim Hortons has not addressed this properly,” John Miziolek, brand strategist and co-founder of Reset Branding. “We have an iconic Canadian brand that is being dragged through the mud.”

A week ago, when reports circulated that some Ontario Tim Hortons franchisees had cut employee benefits and paid breaks in response to the province’s minimum wage hikes, Premier Kathleen Wynne accused the franchisees in question of bullying employees. Head office responded by blaming the actions on a “rogue group” of franchisees.

In a fight over minimum wage at Tim Hortons, the worker loses

  In a fight over minimum wage at Tim Hortons, the worker loses With both Tim Hortons franchisees and the company’s head office refusing to absorb the costs of higher wages, front-line workers are paying the price by having their benefits cut.

WatchTim Hortons getting ' dragged through the mud ' and iconic brand isn ' t doing anything to stop it . The president’s spat with the iconic motorcycle maker over tariffs escalated today.

Then things escalated into multiple protests on-site at stores, calls for boycotts on social media (e.g. #NoTimmiesTuesday), and media headlines like the one in last week’s Financial Post that read: “ Tim Hortons getting ‘ dragged through the mud ’ and iconic brand isn ’ t doing anything to stop it .”

Since then, the brand has stayed mum as the outcry has only intensified this week with a social media movement, “No Timmies Tuesday,” encouraging consumers to boycott the chain, and organized labour protests outside several Ontario Tim Hortons restaurants on Wednesday. When asked for further comment afterwards, Tim Hortons referred to its statements from last week.

President of Ontario Federation of Labour Chris Buckley addresses protesters outside a Tim Hortons Franchise in Toronto.

The latest blowup highlights ongoing franchisee discontent three years after Tim Hortons was bought by Brazilian investment firm 3G Capital and merged with Burger King to form Restaurant Brands International Inc.

The deal brought 3G’s cost-cutting playbook to Canada, along with more stringent rules and benchmarks for franchisees, who saw a big shift in the corporate culture, a change in suppliers and a less direct relationship with the new head office management.

Great White North

Last year, a group of unhappy franchisees banded together to form the Great White North Franchisee Association (GWNFA), saying a number of concerns, including declining product quality, were not being addressed by management. GWNFA’s membership now accounts for more than half of the company’s 1,100 franchisees in Canada.

Don’t Boycott Tim Hortons — Boycott its Stock

  Don’t Boycott Tim Hortons — Boycott its Stock Investors ought to forget about boycotting Tim Hortons, owned by franchisor Restaurant Brands International Inc. (TSX:QSR)(NYSE:QSR). Boycott its stock instead.TRCO

.@Office Want to cancel the automatic renewal for Office 365 but it won't get me log into my email, says it 's been hacked and won't accept my phone # to send a Tim Hortons getting ' dragged through the mud ' as franchise fight escalates — and the iconic brand isn ' t doing anything to stop it http

Tim Hortons has lashed out at franchise owners who have cut paid breaks and other perks for their employees by calling the moves reckless, as finger-pointing over Ontario's minimum-wage hike escalates .

Chris Buckley: President of Ontario Federation of Labour Chris Buckley addresses protesters outside a Tim Hortons Franchise in Toronto.© President of Ontario Federation of Labour Chris Buckley addresses protesters outside a Tim Hortons F... President of Ontario Federation of Labour Chris Buckley addresses protesters outside a Tim Hortons Franchise in Toronto.

Ken Wong, marketing professor at Queen’s University’s School of Business, said the escalating public battle goes against Tim Horton’s classic, wholesome image.

“Tim Hortons presents itself as everyman’s coffee shop — it’s all about kids and community and charity and good things,” Wong said.

“In a better-run business, head office would try to resolve the problem with franchisees without airing the dirty laundry in public. The fact that they couldn’t do that says volumes to me about the state of management at Tim Hortons. But this is something that happens quite often, unfortunately, when an operating company gets bought out by a financial holding company.”

Profits are up under the new regime, however, and the company’s share price has climbed more than 16 per cent in the past year, closing at $76.65 on Wednesday.

While some social media postings this week suggest customers regard Tim Hortons’ franchisees as the extension of a greedy corporate structure while others see them as a victim of it, the bulk of consumers make no distinction at all between the restaurant owners and the corporation’s head office.

Tims customers fight cutbacks at rallies

  Tims customers fight cutbacks at rallies TORONTO - Protesters who rallied outside Tim Hortons locations across Ontario on Wednesday roasted some franchisees for slashing workers' benefits and breaks in an effort to compensate for the province's minimum wage hike, but many said their gripes would not derail their daily coffee runs. Those who gathered said they were worried staff would be negatively impacted if they boycotted to spite the small handful of franchisees — not necessarily the 16 locations that were targeted — who demanded workers cover a larger share of their dental and health-care benefits and take unpaid breaks to offset the 20 per cent raise to $14 an hour.

As matters escalated , the Team Member contacted local authorities for assistance,” Tim Hortons said in a statement. The company says they are working with the franchise owner and will be “looking into this matter further.”

WatchTim Hortons getting ' dragged through the mud ' and iconic brand isn ' t doing anything to stop it . For Tim 's franchisees, winning will take more than rolling up the rim. McDonald’s says it will pay up to 55% of U.S. franchisees' upgrade costs.

“Tims is Tims is Tims,” said crisis-management expert Jim MacLean, president of Toronto-based Tactical Advice/Strategic Communications Inc. “The head office types wish this weren’t true at the moment, as evidenced by the statement distancing themselves from the actions of some of the franchise owners.”

Lawsuits

The franchisee association has filed several class action lawsuits against its corporate parent in the past year for allegedly hiking costs to franchisees and squeezing profits.

The association has said many franchisees would be in financial straits after paying a higher minimum wage because head office will not allow them to increase retail prices. Head office has control over menu prices and the costs of supplies that franchisees must buy from it. The most recent small price increases were put through in August, and were not related to the minimum wage hike. Those corresponding costs have forced some franchisees to cut paid employee breaks and paid benefits, according to the GWNFA.

“It’s hard to understand why they thought this was a good idea,” MacLean said. “Perhaps they did understand there would be negative fallout and they hoped that would force the hand of head office. If that was the strategy, it was a very high-risk, scorched earth policy and it’s burned the brand.”

It comes as Tim Hortons has faced ongoing industry pressure from McDonald’s Canada, whose market share in coffee has climbed in the past five years thanks to a reformulated house blend and new espresso drinks, as well as multiple free coffee giveaways.

McDonald’s franchisees appear to have another advantage in light of the minimum wage hike — they are allowed to set their own menu prices.

“Franchisees are independent business owners and have control over many aspects of their business, including pricing,” said spokesman Adam Grachnik. “Prices for menu items may vary by restaurant.”

Miziolek believes Restaurant Brands International needs to make a concerted effort to repair its damaged relationship with franchisees in Canada, or the Tim Hortons brand will deteriorate.

“I know they want to expand Tim Hortons in the U.S. and elsewhere, but I really think they have taken their eye off the brand in Canada where it started,” he said.

“Brands communicate on the emotional front and the rational front. This is screwing around with the emotional side of what this brand means to Canadians.”

Financial Post

hshaw@nationalpost.com

Twitter.com/HollieKShaw

Tim Hortons franchise owners tell workers to blame Wynne for benefit cuts and to 'not vote Liberal' .
A staff memo written by a couple of Tim Hortons franchise owners in Whitby, Ont., blames cuts to employee benefits on the Ontario government and its minimum wage hike. define("homepageFinanceIndices", ["c.deferred"], function () { var quotesInArticleFormCode = "PRMQAP"; var config = {}; config.indexdetailsurl = "/en-ca/money/indexdetails"; config.stockdetailsurl = "/en-ca/money/stockdetails"; config.funddetailsurl = "/en-ca/money/funddetails"; config.etfdetailsurl = "/en-ca/money/etfdetails"; config.recentquotesurl = "/en-ca/money/getrecentquotes"; config.

Source: http://ca.pressfrom.com/news/money/-59526-tim-hortons-getting-dragged-through-the-mud-as-franchise-fight-escalates-and-the-iconic-brand-isn-t-doing-anything-to-stop-it/

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
This is interesting!